Sheila Polito

Sheila Polito is the ultimate matchmaker — not for couples, but for people and the homes they fall in love with. A true local with deep roots in the greater Princeton area, Sheila brings her insider knowledge of neighborhoods, schools, and lifestyle to every client she works with. Born and raised in Pennington, a graduate of The Pennington School and The College of New Jersey, she now calls beautiful Franklin Township, home.

As a mom and seasoned real estate pro with a decade of experience, Sheila understands the unique priorities of families — from school districts to community vibes — and brings a deeply personal touch to every transaction. She’s successfully closed homes across a range of price points, including luxury properties over $1 million, and is known for guiding her clients with care, clarity, and strategy every step of the way.

Her background in social and corporate event planning shaped her strengths in negotiation, attention to detail, and communication — all essential in today’s market. Clients describe Sheila as grounded, easy to talk to, and fiercely dedicated. Whether you’re buying your first home, upsizing, downsizing, or relocating, she brings calm to the chaos and turns what can be a stressful process into a seamless (and even fun!) experience.

When she’s not touring homes or negotiating deals, you’ll find her on local trails, baking with her kids, or checking out hidden gems across the Princeton area with her husband, Joe, and their rescue pup, Doll.